As a visitor to Milton, I couldn’t help but be intrigued by the local dining scene, and one cuisine, in particular, caught my eye – Italian. Among the array of eateries, there’s one charming Italian restaurant that has piqued my interest. Tucked away in this quaint town, the restaurant exudes an inviting atmosphere that beckons me inside.
I’ve heard wonderful things about their authentic pasta dishes, wood-fired pizzas, and delectable desserts, and I can’t wait to indulge in these Italian delights. As a first-time visitor, I’m eager to experience the warm hospitality and savor the flavors of Italy, right here in Milton.
Explore the wonders of Italian food in Etobicoke which is a neighbouring district! You’ll love the charms this place has too!
From the reviews and recommendations, it promises to be a memorable culinary journey that I’m excited to embark upon. Here’s some of the best Italian restaurant Milton that you gotta try.
1. Locanda
At Locanda, our cozy evening of classic Italian dining began with warm, homemade rolls served alongside balsamic vinegar and olive oil for dipping. For appetizers, we delighted in the shrimp, calamari, and bruschetta, all of which were excellent choices. The array of entrées available was impressive, ranging from seafood pasta and chicken parmigiana to spaghetti aglio olio, gnocchi, and the tantalizing rigatoni mixed in a massive parmigiana wheel – a true standout!
The level of service we experienced in this Italian restaurant Milton was impeccable, with four different servers attentively ensuring that our table had everything we needed. Personally, I thoroughly enjoyed their sea bass and the delectable seafood pasta, especially when paired with their house-made spicy oil, a must-try for any spice lover. The restaurant offered friendly and professional service, leaving us eager to return and explore even more of their delectable dishes.
On another visit, we relished the lobster ravioli, which was absolutely delicious, while my son savored the flavorful chicken parm. The cheese ball they mixed the pasta in was a delightful addition, and the meatballs were equally enjoyable.
The quality of service and scrumptious food were just as impressive as always. This Italian restaurant Milton is truly is a gem nestled on Main Street in Milton, and despite our late request, they accommodated us with grace. The food’s quality, taste, and portion sizes made the entire experience utterly worth it, and this charming spot is well worth the trip. The pasta served from a wheel of cheese was a unique and delightful touch.
The patio, where we chose to sit, was spacious, creating a nice and vibrant atmosphere. The friendly staff contributed to the enjoyable ambiance, and the fettuccini alfredo was a particular favorite among our group. We wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Locanda to others.
During our visit, we relished a range of dishes, including Bruschetta, Salad, Salmon, and refreshing drinks. Every item we tried was filled with flavor and left our taste buds satisfied and delighted.
Website: https://www.lalocandaitaliana.com/
Address: 175 Main St E, Milton, ON L9T 1N7
2. Pasqualino
At Locanda, our cozy evening of classic Italian dining began with warm, homemade rolls served alongside balsamic vinegar and olive oil for dipping. For appetizers, we delighted in the shrimp, calamari, and bruschetta, all of which were excellent choices. The array of entrées available was impressive, ranging from seafood pasta and chicken parmigiana to spaghetti aglio olio, gnocchi, and the tantalizing rigatoni mixed in a massive parmigiana wheel – a true standout!
The level of service we experienced was impeccable, with four different servers attentively ensuring that our table had everything we needed. Personally, I thoroughly enjoyed their sea bass and the delectable seafood pasta, especially when paired with their house-made spicy oil, a must-try for any spice lover. The Italian restaurant Milton offered friendly and professional service, leaving us eager to return and explore even more of their delectable dishes.
On another visit, we relished the lobster ravioli, which was absolutely delicious, while my son savored the flavorful chicken parm. The cheese ball they mixed the pasta in was a delightful addition, and the meatballs were equally enjoyable.
Our recent return visit since before the pandemic did not disappoint; the quality of service and scrumptious food were just as impressive as always. Locanda truly is a gem nestled on Main Street in Milton, and despite our late request, they accommodated us with grace. The food’s quality, taste, and portion sizes made the entire experience utterly worth it, and this charming spot is well worth the trip. The pasta served from a wheel of cheese was a unique and delightful touch.
The patio, where we chose to sit, was spacious, creating a nice and vibrant atmosphere. The friendly staff contributed to the enjoyable ambiance, and the fettuccini alfredo was a particular favorite among our group. We wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this Italian restaurant Milton to others.
During our visit, we relished a range of dishes, including Bruschetta, Salad, Salmon, and refreshing drinks. Every item we tried was filled with flavor and left our taste buds satisfied and delighted.
Website: https://www.lalocandaitaliana.com/
Address: 175 Main St E, Milton, ON L9T 1N7
3. Casa Americo Italian Bistro & Restaurant
My delightful experience at Casa Americo Italian Bistro & Restaurant began as we chose to sit outside on the beautifully lit patio with awesome music playing in the background. The food presentation was impeccable, and every dish tasted incredibly delicious. It was evident that the restaurant is family-owned, as they treated us like “family” from the moment we stepped in.
A true gem in Downtown Milton, this Italian restaurant Milton has been serving delightful food for decades, and I can’t wait to return for more of their scrumptious dishes and impeccable service. I also appreciated that they warmly welcomed young children, acknowledging their importance in the future of fine dining.
During my visit, I had the pleasure of trying the New York Steak with roasted potatoes, perfectly complemented by a Cabernet Sauvignon red wine. The Tiramisu is an absolute must-try and highly recommended.
The menu of this Italian restaurant Milton offers a variety of recommended dishes, including the Chocolate Cake, Bruschetta, Ravioli Del Quattro Formaggio, Chicken Parmesan, Creme Brulee, Lamb Shank, Grilled Salmon, and Veggies. Each one is a delightful culinary experience.
Overall, my experience at Casa Americo was fantastic. The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, the service was top-notch, and the food was truly outstanding. I appreciated the owners’ presence and pleasant demeanor. It’s safe to say that I’ll be returning to this wonderful restaurant.
We ordered the rigatoni jambalaya and the gnocchi for our main dishes. The rigatoni jambalaya was delicious, but we found the gnocchi to be a bit bland. For dessert, we savored the authentic tiramisu, which was a rare find. The wine options were reasonably priced, and we appreciated the availability of half-litre options. The overall prices at the Italian restaurant Milton were very reasonable, making it a place we would love to visit again.
Website: https://casaamerico.com/
Address: 144 Main St E, Milton, ON L9T 1N6
4. The Grand Chalet & Tony Spiducci Ristorante
My dining experience at The Grand Chalet & Tony Spiducci Ristorante was nothing short of fantastic. We started with a Caesar salad, which turned out to be one of the best Caesars I’ve ever had. The gnocchi and agnolotti were super delicious, and I can’t recommend them enough.
During our visit to this Italian restaurant Milton, four of us thoroughly enjoyed the antipasto platter with bruschetta, followed by mouthwatering dishes like gnocchi, penne alla vodka, and lamb spiducci with salad. Each dish was cooked to perfection, and the service provided was impeccable. If you’re seeking authentic Italian cuisine, this restaurant comes highly recommended. We left with the certainty that we will definitely be returning for more delightful meals.
From their recommended dishes, I tried the Speducci, Bruschetta, Tiramisu, Antipasto Grand Chalet, Shrimp, and Calamari, all of which were exceptional. The Italian restaurant Milton creates an atmosphere reminiscent of an Italia chalet, adding to the overall experience.
I particularly enjoyed the special veal dish, which was cooked to perfection, adding to the authentic Italian experience. The staff was friendly and helpful, and the prices were reasonable, offering a good variety of options on the menu.
Though the main entrance may seem like an empty banquet hall, the restaurant’s side door leads to a warm and inviting dining space. The portions were generous, and we were too full to try their desserts, but we will definitely make room for them on our next visit.
I highly recommend this Italian restaurant Milton for its great atmosphere, friendly staff, and outstanding authentic Italian cuisine.
Website: https://www.thegrandchalet.ca/
5. Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza
Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza is a delightful discovery on the outskirts of Toronto. We kicked off our meal with a plate of calamari, and it was so good that we ended up ordering more. The pizzas were absolutely delicious and satisfyingly filling. As a beer lover, I highly recommend trying their house dark and amber beers – they won’t disappoint. The only challenge we faced was finding parking, but the experience at Goodfellas made it all worthwhile.
Stepping into this pizzeria felt like being transported directly to Italy, thanks to its charming ambiance. The wait staff was friendly, and our dining experience was truly enjoyable. Reserving a table is advisable, especially during weekends when the place tends to get crowded. The margarita pizza we tried was scrumptious, and the Caesar salad, served in generous portions, made for a satisfying entree. If you’re looking for a delicious meal, this is the place to stop by.
The pizzas we ordered were excellent, and the staff was accommodating enough to add chicken to a vegetarian pizza for me, even though it wasn’t listed on the menu. The servers were courteous and helpful, making our dining experience even more enjoyable. The drink selection was pretty good, but I made a slightly regretful decision by opting for Zeppole for dessert, which turned out to be a bit too eggy for my taste. Next time, I’m eager to try the tempting Tiramisu.
This Italian restaurant Milton truly lives up to its fantastic reputation. The menu offers a wide variety of options, ensuring that there’s something for everyone’s taste preferences. Our food arrived on time, and the portions were ample, leaving us satisfied but unable to finish it all. The server/host was exceptional, patiently answering our questions before we made our orders. It’s safe to say we’ll be returning for more delightful meals.
During our visit at a busy time, we couldn’t resist trying the cult favorite Diavola pizza, which lived up to its reputation. The calamari was fresh and delightful, and the tomato basic mozzarella salad was simply amazing. There’s no doubt that we’ll be coming back to Goodfellas for another wonderful dining experience.
Website: https://www.goodfellaspizza.ca/menu
Address: 22 Ontario St S, Milton, ON L9T 2M6
6. Portabello's Italian Bistro
Portabello’s Italian Bistro offers a delightful journey into the world of Italian cuisine. The menu is thoughtfully curated, keeping it simple and approachable. The staff, especially our server Chad, was incredibly knowledgeable and provided excellent recommendations, enhancing our dining experience.
From appetizers to main entrees and desserts, the food was nothing short of greatness. The use of fresh ingredients and straightforward preparation resulted in dishes served in a reasonable time, without compromising on taste and quality.
What a pleasant surprise this place turned out to be! The food was incredibly tasty; we particularly enjoyed the pasta, mussels, and garlic bread with cheese – even the bread was outstanding! Carlos, our attentive and friendly server, added to the positive experience. The Italian restaurant Milton atmosphere, along with its lovely patio seating, made for a great dining ambiance. Highly recommended for a delightful Italian culinary adventure.
The bruschetta was a delectable treat, perfectly balanced with just the right amount of garlic and a drizzle of balsamic. The penne ala vodka, lobster ravioli, and shrimp linguine were scrumptious, satisfying our taste buds. To top it off, the chocolate chip skillet cookie and ice cream were the perfect way to end the meal on a high note. We complemented our meal with Grey Goose and iced Cranberry, along with sambuca, making it a delightful and indulgent experience.
While Portabello’s is a decent place with good food, it’s essential to approach the word “Italian” with a hint of skepticism. It may not be an entirely authentic Italian spot, but it does offer enjoyable eatery-style Italian dishes. The pizza in this Italian restaurant Milton was okay, and the Alfredo pasta was good, making it a suitable choice for casual Italian food cravings while in Milton.
Website: https://portabellositalianbistro.ca/
Address: 10220 Derry Rd W, Milton, ON L9T 7J3
7. La Toscana
La Toscana is truly a remarkable Italian eatery that offers an upscale dining experience. One evening, we visited for drinks and were immediately impressed by the exceptional service provided by a gentleman who took care of us. The experience was so delightful that we decided to return the following evening for more drinks and dessert. The Cabernet Sauvignon comes highly recommended and did not disappoint!
For dessert, we indulged in Tiramisu, Chocolate and Raspberry ice cream, New York Cheesecake, and the Cheeseboard. Each dish was a delight, leaving us with clean plates all around. La Toscana has become one of our favorite Italian spots in downtown Milton. Their food is consistently amazing, with fresh oysters, diverse specials, and delicious menu staples. The wide selection of wine adds to the overall experience, and the staff’s warmth and friendliness create an inviting atmosphere. We highly recommend making reservations due to its popularity, although they do accommodate walk-ins as well.
This place is the epitome of great food and outstanding service. It has easily become my absolute favorite Italian restaurant Milton! Words cannot fully describe the hidden gem that La Toscana is, offering a little taste of heaven. Pasquale, the owner, is truly exceptional, and his Amaretto Sours are the best you’ll ever taste! The salmon and cheesecake are must-try dishes, cooked with love and incredible attention to detail.
During our weekly dates here, we have tried every appetizer on the menu and found excitement in each one. Our favorites include the Mussels with cream sauce, fresh oysters, beef carpaccio, and bruschetta. The Caprese salad was also enjoyed by my partner, although a touch less sweetness would have been perfect for their taste. I should mention that the escargot appetizer is unique and special, but it may appeal more to cheese and mushroom lovers.
La Toscana is so exceptional that we even ordered takeout from them on a rainy day. Trust me, this restaurant is a MUST visit. When you go, be sure to say hello to the welcoming owner Pasquale and mention that Nina sent you!
Website: https://www.latoscana.ca/
Address: 165 Main St E, Milton, ON L9T 1N7
8. Luigi's Lasagna & Pizzeria
Luigi’s Lasagna & Pizzeria offers a delightful combination of pizza and pasta that won’t disappoint. I thoroughly enjoyed their pizza and pasta dishes, and I’m already looking forward to trying their veal parm on my next order. The staff is incredibly friendly, courteous, and informative, making the dining experience even more enjoyable.
One of the best parts about Luigi’s is that it’s open 24 hours, which is a huge bonus for late-night cravings. They have earned several awards for being the best pizza in Milton, and I can see why! The Fettuccine Alfredo was rich and creamy, and the Tuscan pizza was quite tasty.
During my visits, I had their delicious lasagna and fantastic chicken parm, which came in large portions. On another occasion, I ordered the ravioli with the most amazing sauce. Each dish exceeded my expectations, and I can’t wait to explore more of their menu options during my next visit.
I recently placed an order for a large poutine, onion rings, classic burger, and a medium regular crust Margherita pizza, all for just $30. The value was outstanding as it easily fed a minimum of three people. The pizza surpassed my expectations, and the onion rings remained crispy. The poutine was slightly salty from the gravy, but still tasty. The classic burger was delicious, and I appreciated the option to add toppings like pickles and hot peppers.
Luigi’s has become my go-to place for consistently delicious pizzas. Their thick and real pepperoni stands out, and I find myself ordering from them multiple times a week. It’s one of those places where you want to call and compliment the cook for their exceptional work.
This Italian restaurant Milton offers the best pizza and pasta in town. Their quality and taste are consistent, making it a reliable choice for a delightful dining experience.
Website: https://www.luigislasagna.com/
Address: 17 Commercial St, Milton, ON L9T 2H6
9. East Side Mario's
East Side Mario’s in Milton offers an amazing dining experience with excellent food, service, and ambiance. I personally prefer this location over the Heartland one. The staff is responsive and attentive, making sure to remember and accommodate requests. The freshly baked bread and deliciously cooked soups and pastas are a highlight.
Our server, Amelia, was an absolute delight, adding to our overall satisfaction with the food, portions, and service. It was such a pleasant experience that it made us contemplate moving to Milton, as finding decent fare in Toronto can be challenging. The Caesar salad was the best I’ve had in a long time, and the wedding soup was delightful. The pasta dishes were filling and satisfying.
One thing I particularly love about East Side Mario’s is the free refills for salads and soups, which is a delightful bonus. I personally ordered the Chicken Parmesan, and it was hot and perfectly cooked without any complaints. What stood out to me was the restaurant’s commitment to customer service and food quality.
The Italian wedding soup is a favorite, and when I’m watching my diet and avoiding bread, pasta, and pizza, the bass fillet is an excellent choice. The servers are friendly, and the atmosphere is cozy, creating a pleasant dining experience.
For those with hearty appetites, the all-you-can-eat bread, salad, or soup option is a fantastic value. The Italian restaurant Milton provides a consistently enjoyable dining experience with a wide range of options, making it an ideal choice for a satisfying dinner.
Website: https://www.eastsidemarios.com/en/menu.html
Address: 860 Main St E, Milton, ON L9T 0J4
10. Gino's Pizza Milton
Gino’s Pizza in Milton offers a delightful range of delicious pizzas and various options to satisfy every taste. I opted for the tandoori chicken and tandoori paneer pizza, paired with popper rolls, and I was impressed with the fresh ginger garlic and tandoori marination flavors. The customer service was exceptional, and I’m already looking forward to trying other options on their menu.
For vegetarians, Gino’s Pizza provides plenty of choices. They offer a variety of vegetarian pizzas on their menu, and you can even create your own customized vegetarian pizza. The best part is that they have halal toppings available, making it inclusive for everyone. I personally love getting the grilled chicken and green peppers with garlic drizzle, and it’s always fresh and delicious.
The crust is the real standout – it’s soft yet crunchy, striking the perfect balance. The staff is friendly, helpful, and maintains a clean environment. The pizza toppings are generous, and you can truly taste the love in every bite. It has become my go-to spot for a satisfying pizza experience.
One of Gino’s Pizza’s game-changers is their new chicken shawarma pizza. With stringy cheese and a delightful crust, it quickly became my favorite pizza in town. Their sauce is the perfect complement to the cheesy goodness. The wide variety of toppings allows for endless combinations, and their great deals offer excellent value for money.
I also had the pleasure of trying their poutine, and it was the best I’ve had. Surprisingly, the gravy was vegetarian, which was a pleasant surprise. Additionally, the chicken bites were a delightful addition to the meal. The staff took their time to help me decide among the various options, and their patience was appreciated. Overall, I highly recommend this Italian restaurant Milton for a memorable and mouthwatering pizza experience.
Website: https://ginospizza.ca/
11. Risposta Bistro
Risposta Bistro offers an impeccable dining experience that goes above and beyond expectations. The attention to detail in each dish, from the homemade pasta to the fresh arugula salad, showcases their dedication to quality. My guests couldn’t stop raving about the food, and the fantastic service ensured that the day went smoothly.
Every visit to this Italian restaurant Milton is a true delight. They not only serve the best quality food with exquisite presentation, but they also create a whole dining experience that leaves a lasting impression. From the moment you step in until the moment you leave, you’re treated to unparalleled service and amazingly creative dishes.
The team at Risposta Bistro, led by Patrick and Dmitry, consistently goes the extra mile to provide exceptional meals and service. Their farm-to-table approach ensures that the food is fresh and delicious, with ingredients sourced from their own grounds. The Parmesan cheese wheel pasta with cognac presentation is a must-see and must-try experience.
The Italian restaurant Milton beautiful property and well-designed outdoor dining area add to the overall charm. They take pride in showcasing their fresh ingredients, grown on-site in the chicken coop and greenhouse. It’s a pleasure to know exactly where your meal is coming from and to witness their farm-to-plate philosophy in action.
Risposta Bistro is truly a gem among dining establishments, offering an unmatched experience that combines delectable cuisine, impeccable service, and a unique farm-to-table journey.
Website: https://www.rispostabistro.com/
After exploring the diverse Italian restaurants in Milton, I can confidently say that the culinary experiences have been nothing short of delightful. From the cozy trattorias to the upscale eateries, each Italian restaurant Milton offered its unique charm and delectable dishes.
The authentic flavors of Italy found at these establishments were a true treat for my taste buds. The pasta dishes, wood-fired pizzas, and tantalizing desserts left me craving for more. The warm and friendly service added an extra touch to the overall dining experience. Whether it was a family-owned pizzeria or an upscale bistro, the love for Italian cuisine was evident in every bite.
The Italian restaurants in Milton have certainly made their mark, providing an unforgettable journey into the heart of Italy right here in this charming town. I look forward to returning soon to savor more of these delightful Italian delights.
More to try: Delicious Italian food in Oakville.
Valerie, Travel Blogger
Valerie Seow is a prominent Malaysian blogger who has made a significant impact on the digital landscape through her influential online presence.
With her captivating writing style and engaging content, she has amassed a large following and become a respected authority in the blogging community. Her blog covers a diverse range of topics, including travel, food, fashion, and lifestyle, making her appeal to a broad audience both in Malaysia and internationally. Valerie’s ability to connect with her readers on a personal level and share authentic experiences has contributed to her success as a blogger.
One of Valerie’s most notable adventures was her visit to Milton, a charming town in Canada. Her travel posts about Milton showcased the town’s natural beauty, local attractions, and cultural offerings. As a passionate traveler, Valerie immersed herself in the town’s unique atmosphere and documented her experiences, which further ignited her readers’ curiosity and wanderlust. Her visit to Milton not only promoted the destination but also highlighted her ability to curate compelling travel content that resonates with her audience.
Valerie Seow’s impact as a Malaysian blogger and influencer extends beyond her impressive travel experiences. Through her platform, she actively engages in social and environmental issues, advocating for positive change and promoting sustainable practices. Her influence reaches far and wide, inspiring others to be more mindful and conscious in their own lifestyles. Valerie’s dedication to authenticity, coupled with her passion for exploration and sharing knowledge, continues to captivate readers and solidify her position as one of Malaysia’s most influential bloggers.
